Skip to main contentSkip to main content
You have permission to edit this article.

Missouri judge weighing lawsuits over photo ID law

A Missouri judge is weighing two lawsuits against a new state law on voter photo identification and civic engagement rules

  • 0

JEFFERSON CITY, Mo. (AP) — Attorneys argued in court Friday over two lawsuits challenging a new Missouri law on voter photo identification and civic engagement rules.

The hearing over how and whether the lawsuits should proceed was held before a judge in Cole County.

The lawsuits, filed by the ACLU of Missouri and the Missouri Voter Protection Coalition, target a sweeping law enacted last month that primarily requires voters to show government-issued photo ID at the polls to cast a regular ballot. Voters without proper ID can cast a provisional ballot, which will be counted if they return with valid ID that same day or if their signature is verified by local election officials.

Plaintiffs include the Missouri NAACP and the Missouri League of Women Voters.

Lawyers for Missouri's Attorney General's Office, which is defending the law in court, asked Cole County Presiding Judge Jon Beetem to dismiss the lawsuit on photo ID requirements.

Solicitor General John Sauer said the concern that some voters won't be able to obtain proper identification in order to cast regular ballots amounts to “speculation at its finest.” And he said Boone County and St. Louis County election officials rarely decline to verify voter signatures on provisional ballots.

“They haven’t identified a single voter who can't vote in November,” Sauer told Beetem during the hearing.

Tony Rothert, of the Missouri ACLU, asked for a trial on the case before the upcoming Nov. 8 elections.

He said the photo ID requirement puts unconstitutional burdens on the right to vote and serves no purpose.

“There's still no evidence of voter-impersonation fraud at the polls," Rothert said, referring to the type of fraud the photo ID is intended to prevent.

Republican Missouri lawmakers passed the law in May after a nearly two-decade push for stricter voting requirements to ensure election integrity.

Seventeen states besides Missouri had voter photo identification laws in effect as of this spring, according to the National Conference of State Legislatures, and 19 states had identification laws that accepted proof other than photos.

A lesser known provision in the Missouri measure bans payment for anyone who works to help register voters and requires those volunteers to be registered Missouri voters themselves. Anyone who helps register more than 10 voters would need to sign up with the Secretary of State’s Office.

The law also bans groups and individuals from “soliciting” voters to request absentee ballots. Violations are punishable by up to five years imprisonment, the loss of the right to vote, and a fine of between $10,000 and $250,000.

The plaintiffs want Beetem to pause that portion of the law as the lawsuit continues.

Campaign Legal Center attorney Danielle Lang said the League of Women Voters of Missouri threw out blank stacks of absentee ballot applications that volunteers had planned to distribute before the law took effect. She said the Missouri NAACP is opting not to talk about absentee voting at all this election cycle over fear of possible prosecution.

“The State of Missouri has made it a felony to approach your neighbor and say, ‘Hey, I would really encourage you to apply to vote absentee,’” Lang said during Friday's court hearing.

Beetem asked that attorneys file proposed orders on the civic engagement lawsuit within the next week. He did not indicate when he might rule on the photo identification requirement.

Copyright 2022 The Associated Press. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed without permission.

* I understand and agree that registration on or use of this site constitutes agreement to its user agreement and privacy policy.

Related to this story

Most Popular

Police say a man was killed and a patrol officer was injured during a shooting in a shopping area near a major crossroads in suburban Henderson. Officer Alan Olvera says the shooting happened a little before 7 a.m. Monday after officers responded to a report of a person with a gun at a business on Eastern Avenue near St. Rose Parkway. Olvera says the man was shot by police when he produced what was believed to be a handgun. The man died at a hospital and the officer was in stable condition with injuries that were not described. Names were not immediately disclosed. Henderson police cordoned off a wide area near a shopping center for several hours and detoured traffic away during their investigation.

One person has been killed and three others wounded in a shooting at a block party in eastern Georgia. The Jefferson County Sheriff’s Office says numerous shots were fired at the Saturday gathering in Louisville while more than 100 people were present. The person who was killed was pronounced dead at a hospital in Louisville. Two victims were taken to a hospital in Augusta, while one was treated for minor injuries and released from the Louisville hospital. The sheriff’s office did not release names of any of the victims. Investigators say that multiple weapons were fired multiple times, hitting the victims and some vehicles.

Four people have died after a late-night crash on U.S. 61 in Mississippi’s Delta region. The Mississippi Highway Patrol says two vehicles collided head-on near Valley Park in Issaquena County just before midnight on Saturday. Troopers say that 39-year-old Jackson resident Thomas Williams Jr. was driving a Honda Accord southbound with 17-year-old Thomas K. Williams as a passenger. The car hit a northbound Nissan driven by 43-year-old Kamille H. Smith of Cleveland with 16-year-old Kirstin A. Lucas as a passenger. Troopers did not state a cause for the wreck and are investigating. Cleveland Central High School says Lucas was a student there. Smith was her mother.

The body of a missing boater has been recovered from Lay Lake in central Alabama. Sgt. Jeremy Burkett of the Alabama Law Enforcement Agency says searchers on Sunday found the body of David D. Etheridge, 51, of Hoover in the Spring Creek section of the lake in Shelby County. Authorities began searching for Etheridge Saturday after finding his new bass boat floating abandoned on the lake. Burkett didn’t say how officials believe Etheridge died. Lay Lake is reservoir on the Coosa River southeast of Birmingham.

Authorities say five firefighters were injured while battling a house fire in Ohio over the weekend. Officials said the blaze was reported in a home in Springfield at about 2 p.m. Tuesday. Assistant Chief Matt Smith said crews were on the second floor when the fire suddenly took off — which he said may have been a flashover — and firefighters were ordered to evacuate. The Springfield News-Sun reports that one firefighter was flown to Miami Valley Hospital in Dayton. Smith said four other firefighters were also transported to hospitals for treatment. There was no immediate word on the condition of those injured. The cause of the fire remains under investigation.

Authorities say a black bear died after being struck by a car on a remote highway in Southern California. The Kern County Fire Department says the collision happened Thursday night on State Route 178 near Lake Isabella, at the southern end of the Sierra Nevada. The department says the driver was not hurt, but the airbags deployed and the car sustained front-end damage.  The state Department of Fish and Wildlife was notified. Fire officials say this was the second bear to be hit by a vehicle on State Route 178 in the past two months.

A military recruiter was killed by deputies after authorities say he fatally shot his wife as she was making a domestic violence complaint against him to investigators. Harris County Sheriff Ed Gonzalez says the man’s wife had been speaking with investigators with the Naval Criminal Investigative Service, or NCIS, around 1:30 p.m. on Thursday when she was fatally shot by her husband at their apartment in northern suburban Houston. Gonzalez says as the man ran away, he exchanged gunfire with the NCIS investigators, injuring one of them. Authorities says the man fled the scene and was driving to his mother’s home in northwest Harris County when he shot at deputies with Harris County Constable Precinct 4. The deputies returned fire, killing the man.

A South Carolina sheriff’s deputy is hospitalized and another man is dead after officials say the man opened fire on the deputy Sunday. Sumter County Sheriff Anthony Dennis says a deputy called to a home for a domestic disturbance found a garage on fire. The sheriff says that Leroy Quick Jr. began shooting at the unnamed deputy who was trying to put out the fire. The deputy was wounded and returned fire. Quick was found wounded and unresponsive after other deputies arrived and was pronounced dead at a hospital. The deputy is hospitalized but is expected to recover. The South Carolina Law Enforcement Division is investigating the shooting and fire.

Four former circuit court judges will help handle a backlog of criminal cases that have accumulated in Mississippi’s largest county during the COVID-19 pandemic. Mississippi Supreme Court Chief Justice Mike Randolph appointed Andrew K. Howorth of Oxford, Betty W. Sanders of Greenwood, Stephen B. Simpson of Gulfport and Frank G. Vollor of Vicksburg. Administrative Office of Courts director Greg Snowden says Hinds County has an urgent need to handle cases that were postponed when courtrooms were closed for safety. He says defendants who are found guilty need to go to prison, and those found not guilty need to be released.

Get up-to-the-minute news sent straight to your device.


Breaking News

News Alert